This is a bit old by now, but I’ve been quite busy this weekend.
The front page headline of Friday’s San Francisco Chronicle read: Silence means prison, Judge tells reporters. Apparently two Chronicle reporters are being threatened with jail time for not revealing court sources in their ongoing coverage of the BALCO story.
I know very little about the story. I don’t follow sports at all and I don’t care about steroid use in sports. What I do follow with interest are cases of First Amendment disputes, overarching government authority, and the Drug War. Regardless of the reporters’ opinions on how the whole steroids in baseball controversy should be solved (I’m not aware of what their opinions actually are), the whole issue stems from the War on Drugs.
Were the use of steroids among the general population not a matter of illegality but of personal choice, the issue could have been resolved within Major League Baseball itself. If baseball players had the choice of whether or not to use steroids without the threat of legal action, the only consequences they would face would be the rules of the league or of Major League Baseball. Major League Baseball as a private, voluntary organization is perfectly capable of setting its own rules with regard to its members’ behavior. If they wanted to keep steroids against the rules of the game, they could easily bar any player who infringes upon that rule. (There are those who say let them be permitted.) Also, as a voluntary organization, testing could be mandated in any fashion and players who disagreed with the policy could leave by choice. The Chronicle reporters would still have been covering a fantastic controversy whether or not steroid use was considered illegal by the government.
The fact that this scandal has now resulted in the very real threat of prison for journalists simply doing their jobs is rather shocking. The drug warriors (which include many prosecutors and judges) apparently regard the trampling of rights as insignificant as long as high profile users get busted. That the matter of steroid use among athletes is a higher priority among government prosecutors than the abuses perpetrated by government upon citizens every day appalls me.
technorati tags: baseball, balco, steroids, drugwar, freespeech, freepress